Posts Tagged ‘BBQ’

Dickey’s Barbecue Pit

Saturday, July 14th, 2012

Madison’s east side continues to be a depository of chain restaurants. Will it ever be like its crosstown rival and have a Delaney’s? an Otto’s? an Eno Vino?

Joining the fray recently was Dickey’s Barbecue Pit. Since the Madison area hasn’t seen its likes, I thought I’d write a short review.

I’m a meat lover, and I appreciate being able to combine different types of meats, and that’s something you can do here. On one plate, I tried the brisket and polish sausage. I prefer brisket in slices, but this chopped version was good, albeit a little weak in flavor. It’s really dependent on the sauces, which I’ll get to in a bit. The sausage was actually my favorite item of the day–it was not at all bland like so many poorly constructed links.

On the other plate, I had the Fall-Off-The-Bone Pork Ribs and the southern pulled pork. The ribs were too smoky (re: dry) for my liking, and the pulled pork seemed to be missing the requisite fat. Just like in the case of the brisket, using either the regular, sweet or spicy BBQ sauces really helped the meats. I guess that’s okay when the sauces are good, and they were in this case.

You get two sides and a roll with every plate. I wouldn’t get the jalapeno beans again, as they weren’t at all sweet or spicy. Both the creamy coleslaw and the mac & cheese were fairly standard. The winner was the onion tanglers, which were deep-friend onion pieces (not in a ring) that reminded me of the parts of an onion blossom served at other restaurants.

A pleasant surprise was the free ice cream and pickles (pregnancy craving, anyone?). I added the soft serve vanilla (the only flavor) to my root beer to make a float.

Dickey’s Barbecue Pit is open every day for lunch, dinner and carryout. Catering is available, too.

Dickey's Barbecue Pit on Urbanspoon

Papa Bear’s BBQ

Sunday, May 13th, 2012
Although I usually write about new restaurants, I wanted to give a shout-out to the oft-overlooked Papa Bear’s BBQ, which resides in a small strip mall on Cottage Grove Road. Madisonians tend to think of places like Smoky Jon’s when asked about barbecue joints, and that’s a shame because they’re missing a gem in Papa Bear’s.

It starts with the ribs. I ordered the full slab ($19 for the meal), which is served with the individual ribs pre-cut. The meat is extremely tender and there’s just the right amount of Papa Bear’s homemade BBQ sauce to enhance the flavor. In my opinion, that sauce is better than anything found at Smoky Jon’s, Fat Jack’s, Famous Dave’s or Brickhouse BBQ.

I also loved the corned beef brisket ($7.25 for small; $10 for large). The thin-sliced corned beef (misspelled as “corn beef” on the menu) works well outside its usual home inside two slices of rye bread, though I was tempted to stuff some inside the biscuit.

The flavorful pork shoulder ($6.95 for small; $9 for large) was sliced instead of shredded and again served on its own. There was just the right amount of fat on each slice, though that may be a turn-off to some people. I combined bites with the creamy cole slaw, which I also enjoyed. All meals are served with a biscuit and two sides.

My only disappointment was the hot links ($5.25 in a sandwich), not because they weren’t tasty but because they weren’t really that spicy hot. Other items on the menu include smoked chicken ($8.25), oven-fried chicken ($8.25) and the Papa Bear Burger ($5).

Papa Bear’s BBQ is open Monday-Saturday for lunch and dinner. While there is space inside to dine-in, I would recommend calling ahead and carrying out.

Papa Bear's BBQ on Urbanspoon

Porktropolis

Sunday, October 2nd, 2011

From downtown Madison, head 20 minutes east on 151 and exit Bristol Street in Sun Prairie, where you will find a hidden gem called Porktropolis. It’s a meat-lover’s paradise, complete with brisket, chicken, salmon and of course, ribs and pulled pork.

I loved the Exploding Pig ($8.50), which is pork, ham, bacon, cheddar and chipotle mayo on dark rye. The real explosion here is the flavor, which makes puts this sandwich on my must-get-again list for future visits.

The ribs ($12.50 for a half rack) are served naked so that you can add whichever of the sauces you prefer. For the less adventurous crowd, try the Sweet Memphis Blues, which is your typical sweet (and delicious) BBQ sauce.

On the topic of sauces, choices include Door County Cherry, Chipotle Horseradish and Carolina Vinegar, amongst others. You can sample all of them right when you walk in. I thought the NOLA (similar to Buffalo) went well with TC’s Beef Brisket ($7.50), another excellent sandwich.

I’m not a huge fan of mac & cheese, but I was pleasantly surprised by how tasty the Red Pepper Mac Cheese was. In fact, that was the best of the sides. The Creamy Cole Slaw was not that creamy, and the skillet fried potatoes were just so-so. I would have preferred to see fries on the menu, just as another vessel for the sauces.

Porktropolis is open Monday-Saturday and also caters. While there are a few tables, it’s a place you should call ahead for carryout.

    Madison Symphony Orchestra Urban Air

  • Blog Home

    You are currently browsing the EatDrinkMadison.com blog archives.

  • Archives

  • Categories